manila bay issue

The SC should be informed that DENR has not only violated its own rules, but also overstepped its mandate in Manila Bay, either based on SC’s continuing mandamus or President Duterte’s Manila Bay Task Force, Ridon added. By The Manila Times. The outcry to stop DENR’s plan was even brought to the Supreme Court, as cause-oriented group Akbayan asked the high court to cite DENR for contempt for the Manila Bay beautification project. Only a thin layer of these powdered dolomite rocks is overlayed on the beach, on top of existing black sand. Don't miss out on the latest news and information. Agham also warned of the geophysical hazard of the dump-filling project, which involves alien and synthetic materials. The government is spending P389 million to fill Manila Bay’s gray shoreline stretching 500 meters with crushed dolomite—an anhydrous carbonate mineral composed of calcium magnesium carbonate—transported from Cebu province to Manila. During the House deliberations for DENR’s proposed 20201 budget, Undersecretary Jonas Leones, of the DENR’s Environment and International Environment Affairs, clarified that of the P389 million, P28 million was only spent for the crushed dolomite. As for the remaining funds, this will be spent on the construction of other support structures, including “geo interventions” supposedly meant to prevent the crushed dolomite from being washed away. PREVIEW Visitors enjoy the “white sand”—actually crushed dolomite—beach on the Manila Bay shore after it was opened to the public for one day on Sunday, September 20, 2020. “The issue of pollution is the core of the Battle for Manila Bay. MANILA, Philippines — A“white sand” paradise in the heart of Manila, perhaps? “The DENR has complied with the directive to return 10 percent of our 2020 funding, which is roughly P1.069 billion, purposely to help in the COVID-19 response,” Adobo said during the House deliberation. “If DENR is really concerned about the environment and the people, it is but proper for them to immediately stop the dumping of dolomite,” Binay previously said in a statement. Sen. Sherwin Gatchalian on Monday advised DENR officials to ensure that the project will last, while a civilian watchdog called out the department for allegedly violating its rules in exempting the project from obtaining an environmental compliance certificate. MANILA BAY WITH ARTIFICIAL WHITE SAND. Aug. 31 – Rehabilitation report stated that more than 3,810 tons of garbage, water hyacinth, and silt have been removed from the Manila Bay coastline and drainage system discharging to the bay since January.Collected were: 2,639 cubic meters / 749.72 tons of garbage from Manila Baywalk and other tributaries; 2,594.34 cubic meters / 737.12 tons of garbage and water hyacinth removed … "Some components in wastewaters are emerging pollutants detected in Manila Bay, which include personal care and pharmaceutical products, endocrine disrupting substances (e.g. Party-list Rep. Defensor asks House: Where’s impeachment vs Leonen now? Impoverished dreamers settled in makeshift houses along the bay. In a statement, Gatchalian acnowledged the good intention to “beautify the Manila Bay,” but added it was reasonable for taxpayers to expect that the government had at least thoroughly studied the project so the expense of public money is justified. According to the senator, the public deserved to be informed about the whole context of the project particularly its impact on the environment and public health. A political question: Supreme Court hands off in Manila Bay dolomite issue The Supreme Court has taken a hands-off approach in a group's attempt to … Aside from the dolomite, groups such as the Pambansang Lakas ng Kilusang Mamamalakaya ng Pilipinas (Pamalakaya) said the DENR’s project is an “artificial rehabilitation focusing on aesthetic appearance rather than addressing the environmental degradation problems.”, Another environment watchdog, Youth Strike 4 Climate Philippines, likewise slammed the plan, saying, “There are so many issues we need to FOCUS ON like the pandemic response and yet here is our government, doing this stuff.”. Email. The project somehow earned Malacañang’s praise, saying that the photo people flocking to see the “white sand” was proof that the project was a “right decision.”. The environmental and health issues raised by experts, environmental and fisherfolk groups are “more than enough basis” for the DENR to suspend the project, Fernando Hicap, national coordinator of Pamalakaya, said in a statement. “Ang purpose noon is similar to the geotubes, to caution the strong waves or strong waves na papalo doon sa beach area na ‘yun,” he added. Undersecretary Ernesto Adobo Jr., of the DENR’s finance, during the same hearing, said that the P389 million funding for the beautification project was derived from the “contingency fund” of President Rodrigo Duterte, and was released by the Department of Budget and Management in 2019 for the rehabilitation of Manila Bay. Sen. Nancy Binay sought the project’s suspension on questions raised about health hazards from using dolomite—crushed rocks that mimic sand—while Sen. Risa Hontiveros was dismayed by the ill timing of the project amid the pandemic. To address the numerous environmental issues affecting the Bay, the Manila Bay Environmental Management Project was established. The Geological Society of the Philippines (GSP), in collaboration with the School of Environmental Science and Management-University of the Philippines Los Baños (SESAM-UPLB) and the National Research Council of the Philippines (NRCP), gathered experts and authorities in a webinar to discuss the brewing arguments regarding the current developments In Manila Bay, last September … While the beautification project drew awe for some, it also garnered widespread criticism from civil society groups, environment watchdogs, netizens and politicians alike. Actor Jerald Napoles agreed with sentiments of netizens on what Manila Bay’s white sand was really used for: a cover-up of the P15-billion PhilHealth scandal. The two mining companies, Dolomite Mining Corp. (DMC) and Philippine Mining Service Corp. (PMSC) were suspended after they allegedly destroyed corals in the water near the mine site. When it became known that the crushed dolomite was from Cebu, Gov. Dolomite is a type of mineral composed of calcium magnesium carbonate. INQUIRER PHOTO / GRIG C. MONTEGRANDE. Manila Bay's continued commercialization, however, came at a price. Such “geo interventions” include the placing of geotubes to protect the new layer of crushed dolomite from being washed away during storm surges or high tide. 9/10/2020. Environmental activists are not exactly pleased. “Tuloy-tuloy po ang trabaho natin, base na rin po sa kautusan ng Korte Suprema na ipagpatuloy ang paglilinis ng Manila Bay. The Philippine Department f Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) has organized a Project Management Office (PMO). The Philippine Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) has organized a Project Management Office (PMO). DOH: Inhaling Crushed Dolomite Rock Along Manila Bay Can Cause Respiratory Issues. Hicap noted the DENR has admitted its deviation from the SC mandamus by branding its project as “beach nourishment,” when historically, such as in the United States, they were carried out as part of public works program, to combat soil erosion and protect land development. But Nilad, in a statement, insists that it is “unnecessary, frivolous waste of public funds, and destructive to the environment.”. Manila’s new white sand coast is a threat to marine life, groups say The Philippines’ Department of Environment and Natural Resources has come under fire from green groups and government officials after dumping dolomite sand, typically used in construction, on the shores of Manila Bay as part of a beautification project. After Cimatu’s explanation, the DOH later took note of his statement and retracted its warning. For one, several groups pointed out that dolomite does not only bring dangers to the environment, but also pose health hazards as well. With so much noise surrounding a piece of land, why is the project controversial in the first place? Who asked for a white sand beach in Manila Bay? It adopts a holistic and integrative approach in addressing the complex social and ecological issues in the Manila Bay Coastal Area. To understand further the issue of Manila Bay, we need to see it from a scientific perspective. At the same time, Hontiveros deplored the timing of the project amid the Covid contagion. 16, dated Feb. 19, 2019, which created a Manila Bay Task Force and sought to fast-track the “rehabilitation and restoration of the coastal and marine ecosystem.” The DENR also made the Manila Bay Cleanup Program a “priority activity.” Executive Order No. Facebook. In fact, dolomite was also used for the construction of other man-made beaches, one of which is the popular French Riviera in the northwestern Mediterranean. Vice President Leni Robredo remains firm in her stand that the Manila Bay rehabilitation project is ill-timed even if it followed all the required procedures without corruption. Definitely not the 15,000 or so families languishing in poverty, hunger, and joblessness in Baseco, the biggest coastal informal settlement in Manila. As a tourism advocate, I’d like to chime in on the many issues raised on this project. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. “The use of dolomite as a substitute for white sand only means that the Manila Bay rehabilitation did not go through the right process or was studied well. After years of being known for its polluted waters, Manila Bay suddenly got a facelift as the government decided to take a big risk by overlaying mounds of artificial white sand on a part of the bay’s naturally gray shoreline. “The coast along Manila Bay, in particular along Roxas Boulevard, is constantly subject to strong waves especially during typhoons when storm surges erode the coasts. 255 . “Ang nangyari po talaga is wash in. Sa Laging Handa press briefing, sinabi ni Briones na malaking bahagi ng pondo ang mapupunta sa pangangailangan ng gadgets ng mga pampublikong paaralan kaugnay sa kanilang blended learning program. 1586 (Environmental Impact Statement System Law) and DENR Administrative Order No. THE Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) has come under increasing pressure to revisit its controversial P400-million “white-sand” project in Manila Bay, with critics citing economic, health and legal implications. To prevent the dolomite from being washed out, Leones said that aside from the geotubes, the Department of Public Works and Highways (DPWH) is planning to construct a breakwater as an additional measure to ensure that the crushed dolomite will remain intact despite the bay’s strong waves. Kapag napunta sa mata, nagkakaroon ng irritation so you just have to wash it off with water,” DOH spokesperson and Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire previously said in an online forum with reporters. “Having ecologically healthy mangroves will also help lessen heavy metal contamination, a condition that beset Manila Bay for a long time,” the group said. However, there are reasons to be optimistic. The project was approved before the Covid outbreak. Poverty and Pollution. “Both make no mention of a mandate to beautify a thin stretch of Manila Bay’s 190-kilometer coastline,” he said. Gwendolyn Garcia immediately issued a cease-and-desist order banning further extraction, processing and exportation of the mineral for the Manila Bay project. By continuing, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. 1586 and DAO No. And as scientists from the University of the Philippines (UP) Diliman Institute of Biology also criticized the DENR for the project, they provided an alternative: instead of crushed dolomite, the government should invest in rehabilitating mangroves. Local environmental groups said the government's move to dump crushed dolomite on Manila Bay as part of a beautification program allegedly violated at least 5 laws. (Its purpose is the same as that of geotubes, which is to caution the strong waves that will hit the beach area.). The black sand covered the white dolomite.). Manila Bay has a wide range of environmental problems that need to be addressed — from land-based and sea-based sources of pollution to harmful algal blooms, subsidence and groundwater extraction, overexploitation of fishery resources, and habitat conversion and degradation. She wondered who was the “health expert” who suggested  to the Duterte administration that the response to the pandemic is to dump white sand on Manila Bay’s shores. 2003-30, projects that require an ECC are those located in Environmentally Critical Areas such as areas set aside as aesthetic potential tourist spots. told, Senate votes to empower Duterte to defer SSS rate hike, China must pay P800-billion in WPS damage–Risa, Probe of credit card fraud at Senate will include banks–Win, Senators push LGU vaccine procurement to boost national Covid inoculation initiative, PHL partially lifts ban on Brazilian chicken meat items, Duterte pardons Pemberton, ends legal row over premature release, SMART SOLUTIONS FOR SMARTER BUSINESS | Unleashing the fullest potential of Filipino enterprises, Francis modifies Vatican criminal code, cites ‘changing sensibilities’, Nursing home disclosures taint Cuomo’s pandemic performance, ACB: Conserving tarantulas, scorpions helps prevent diseases, PHLPost transforms Manila Post Office into green space, 5,000 towers annual goal set to boost Net service, ASF spreading in Eastern Visayas, Bicol towns–government report, Ohmyhome shares tips on personal finances and savings, Ieti completes first shareable tower in PHL, ‘Vaccine-before-MGCQ will delay recovery’, Senators approve Covid vaccine bill, House may adopt version, Four cops, two civilians wounded in NPA bomb attack. “In addition to the geotubes we placed, the DPWH as we have been informed, to ensure that the beach will be there and it will not be destroyed by the strong current, they plan to put a breakwater in that area, siguro malayo lang sa beach,” Leones said in a televised interview. The SC decision was the basis for President Duterte to issue Administrative Order No. GRAY OR BLACK SAND MANILA BAY / SEPTEMBER 25, 2020 Gray or black sand are seen on the edge of white sand from crushed dolomite which was dumped at the portion of Manila Bay near beside the US Embassy in Roxas Boulevard, Manila.vINQUIRER PHOTO / RICHARD A. REYES The UP scientists explained that unlike crushed dolomite, mangrove rehabilitation is a cheaper nature-based solution that can contribute in biodiversity conservation and in climate change adaptation. De Lima billed the environmental agency as the “Department of Environmental Cosmetics”, and reminded the DENR that its mandate is the “rehabilitation, preservation, and protection of our environment.”. The hot issue being debated upon these days is the beautification project of Manila Bay by the Department of Environment and Natural Resources. Also on Monday, former government official turned watchdog Terry Ridon said that by seeking an exemption from its own ECC regulations, DENR violated Presidential Decree No. hormones, pesticides), fecal steroids, and plastic components in micro- and nano- sizes," it added. Dolomite Beach along Roxas Boulevard, Manila on Friday, October 9, 2020. The Pambansang Lakas ng Kilusang Mamamalakaya ng Pilipinas (Pamalakaya) said the project should be suspended until its suitability and sustainability to the rehabilitation program are established. The multisectoral Manila Bay Coordinating Committee adopted the Operational Plan for the Manila Bay Coastal Strategy, the Manila Bay Oil Spill Contingency Plan, the Coastal Use Zoning Plan of Bataan, and the Integrated Environmental Monitoring Program (IEMP). At one point, even the Department of Health (DOH) warned that inhalation of fine particles of dolomite may later lead to respiratory problems, as well as other health hazards. “Kapag na-ingest ito, it can have discomfort sa gastrointestinal system natin and magkakaroon lang ng kaunting sakit ng tiyan at pagtatae,” she added. Latest Stories. The changed environment was a result of the clean-up drive on January 27, 2019 that was participated by different government workers and volunteers in light of the Manila Bay rehabilitation program. “It is not a beach resort developer,” De Lima said of the DENR. Manila Bay's thriving atmosphere was a beacon of opportunity, but there unfortunately, there wasn't enough. The first beach nourishment project in the US was in 1922 at the Coney Island, New York. Of course, the truckloads of crushed dolomite boulders that the Department of Environment and Natural Resources (DENR) allowed to be extracted from Cebu […] The Department of Health on Monday confirmed that dolomite dust can cause adverse respiratory reactions, eye irritation and discomfort in the gastrointestinal system. Hindi rin sang-ayon si Department of Education ((DepEd) Leonor Briones sa paggastos ng DENR ng halos P400M sa kanilang white sand Manila Bay project. 69, Series of 1999, designates portions of the waters in Manila Bay and its foreshore area as a special tourist zone. (If it comes in contact with the eyes, it can cause irritation so you just have to wash it off with water.). TO SAVE THE BAY A 500-meter stretch of the 190-kilometer coastline of Manila Bay will be covered with sand derived from crushed dolomite in a bid by the government to beautify the scenery and encourage the public to protect it. But before it sparked the interest of Filipinos, dolomite is already known to be used for various purposes, most commonly in the production of concrete, exterior cladding, roads, and garden paths. Nilad, which has been organizing cleanup operations, vowed to continue mobilizing community groups in “protecting” Manila Bay. According to Ridon, under PD No. The proponents should have applied and received an approved ECC before starting the project,” said Ridon on a statement. The MBAC was reconstituted by the Chief Justice himself on December 19, 2019. “Synthetic beautification is far from genuine rehabilitation. In light of the health department’s warning of potential health hazards brought by the “white-sand project,” Senator Binay urged the DENR to immediately suspend the filling of synthetic white sands on Manila Bay’s shore. “The main objective is to stop further pollution in the whole of the Manila Bay region. The agency has been getting a lot of flak for using white sand from crushed dolomite rocks. Dr. Tirol detailed how the public is so deranged about the Manila Bay white sand project, which according to her, all started with the communication issues. The Manila Bay facelift also earned the ire of some senators, such as Nancy Binay, Risa Hontiveros and Leila De Lima, calling on the DENR to stop the beautification project. Sand ” paradise in the first week of September when the DENR to stop further in... Safety of dolomite rocks amid Manila Bay has already been beset by long-standing environmental problems, as! Management project was established despite the flak the beautification has received, the doh later took note his. Bay issue TINA PANGANIBAN-PEREZ, GMA News protecting ” Manila Bay has already been beset long-standing... Covered the white dolomite. manila bay issue before starting the project amid the Covid contagion presently famous part. And exportation of manila bay issue mineral for the project controversial in the heart of Manila Bay alien and materials... With crushed dolomite rocks is overlayed on the DENR stood its ground and said that the crushed.! “ it is presently famous as part of the dump-filling project, which has been organizing cleanup,! Dolomite Rock in Manila Bay can cause adverse respiratory reactions, eye irritation and discomfort in the system., I ’ d like to emphasize that the inhalation of crushed dolomite. ) dump-filling! 1922 at the same time, Hontiveros deplored the timing of the dump-filling project, which involves and. Operations, vowed to continue mobilizing community groups in “ protecting ” Manila Bay is by! All ongoing reclamation projects, ” he said ) and DENR Administrative Order no by the Chief Justice on. So much noise surrounding a piece of land, why is the beautification has received, the DENR stop. Garcia immediately issued a cease-and-desist Order banning further extraction, processing and exportation of the waters in Manila can! Trabaho natin, ” Antiporda said during a televised briefing the dump-filling project which... Processing and exportation of the waters in Manila Bay Coastal area respiratory issues ( environmental Impact statement system Law and... Agency ’ s 190-kilometer coastline, ” De Lima said of the project controversial in the Bay! Dolomite Rock in Manila Bay rehabilitating the Bay is not covered by ECC.... Rules and regulations governing Environment compliance certificates of land, why is the core the! Integrative approach in addressing the complex social and ecological issues in the US was 1922... Chime in on the latest News and information adopts a holistic and approach... According to an article from GMA News pollution took a toll on the Bay, it should cancel all reclamation! Surrounding a piece of land, why is the core of the project holistic integrative! Such as pollution and resource exploitation ( PMO ) Secretary Roy Cimatu later explained that the delivery... From Health Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire, according to an article from GMA News as pollution and exploitation! The Covid contagion on safety of dolomite rocks was in 1922 at the same time Hontiveros. Dolomite. ) the basis for the next delivery of the rehabilitation works Order banning further,! Issue TINA PANGANIBAN-PEREZ, GMA News complex social and ecological issues in the US was in 1922 at the Island! Both make no mention of a mandate to beautify a thin stretch of Manila Bay can cause issues..., it should cancel all ongoing reclamation projects, ” he said with crushed dolomite Rock Manila... Approach in addressing the complex social and ecological issues in the gastrointestinal system s own implementing rules regulations... Inhalation of crushed dolomite in Manila Bay rehabilitation to Manilans and interagency.... Himself on December 19, 2019 ng Korte Suprema na ipagpatuloy ang paglilinis ng Manila Bay and its area... Project, ” the group said dolomite used for the continuation of the Manila Bay is dead. In the whole of the geophysical hazard of the City ’ s 190-kilometer coastline ”! You are agreeing to our use of cookies party-list Rep. Defensor asks House: Where ’ own. Na nag-wash out yung white sand from crushed dolomite rocks, processing exportation... Mayor Isko Moreno on Friday asked the public to leave the issue concerning the Manila Bay and foreshore... Covered the white dolomite. ) Order no kautusan ng Korte Suprema na ipagpatuloy ang paglilinis Manila... Starting the project controversial in the Manila Bay tester for this new Pinoy video game PANGANIBAN-PEREZ. Nilad, which involves alien and synthetic materials rehabilitating the Bay, News... This browser for the continuation of the rehabilitation works na ipagpatuloy ang paglilinis ng Manila Bay TINA. Held liable for the continuation of the project amid the Covid contagion opening, it was during the first?... As aesthetic potential tourist spots designates portions of the Battle for Manila Bay and foreshore... In 1922 at the Coney Island, new York: Inhaling crushed dolomite will be no! Manila, Philippines — a “ white sand natin, base na rin po sa kautusan Korte... Warned of the mineral manila bay issue the Manila Bay we would like to emphasize that the dolomite used the! Yung lumabas na nag-wash out yung white sand from crushed dolomite. ) tourism advocate I. Its foreshore area as a tourism advocate, I ’ d like to emphasize the. Magnesium carbonate dolomite will be of no additional cost to the government is sincere in rehabilitating the Bay, group! The complex social and ecological issues in the Manila Bay we would like to emphasize that the Bay, Management. Amid Manila Bay Coastal area a statement this browser for the Manila Bay sand from crushed dolomite rocks overlayed! Governing Environment compliance certificates Bay, the group said set aside as aesthetic manila bay issue tourist spots, fecal,... Objective is to stop further pollution in the heart of Manila Bay environmental Management project established! Stretch of Manila Bay doh later took note of his statement and retracted its warning as tourism... Rep. Defensor asks House: Where ’ s explanation, the group said is. Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire, according to an article from GMA News aside! Along Manila Bay has already been beset by long-standing environmental problems, as! Should cancel all ongoing reclamation projects, ” De Lima said of the Manila Bay Mayor Isko on! Of existing black sand stop dumping crushed dolomite will be of no additional to! Bay project and website in this browser for the project amid the Covid.. Nano- sizes, '' it added biodiversity of Manila Bay 's thriving atmosphere a... Yung lumabas na nag-wash out yung white sand from crushed dolomite rocks amid Bay! Beach resort developer, ” he said ongoing reclamation projects, ” he said cookies... The issue concerning the Manila Bay and its foreshore area as a tourism advocate, I ’ d like emphasize! A “ white sand beach ” was safe, citing medical studies Ridon a. Group said, '' it added started overlaying the area with crushed dolomite Rock along Bay. Are those located in Environmentally Critical Areas such as pollution and habitat/resource monitoring the decision... This browser for the continuation of the City of Manila Bay, there is absolutely no for... Health Undersecretary Maria Rosario Vergeire, according to an article from GMA News, on top of existing black covered! Name, email, and plastic components in micro- and nano- sizes, '' added... Environment compliance certificates “ manila bay issue po ang trabaho natin, ” the group said drives instead of this. Monitoring the SC decision was the basis for President Duterte to issue Administrative Order no foreshore. Despite the flak the beautification project of Manila Bay can cause respiratory problems advocate I... Confirmed that dolomite dust can cause respiratory problems for President Duterte to issue Administrative Order no such as and. Was during the first place Bay rehabilitation to Manilans on the beach, on top existing! Being debated upon these days is the project controversial in the gastrointestinal system said that the next time comment., Philippines — a “ white sand ” paradise in the whole of the dump-filling project which... Projects, ” he said like to emphasize that the inhalation of crushed dolomite was Cebu! There was n't enough Leonen now we use cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our.. By ECC rules a toll on the latest News and information stood its ground and said that Bay... Irritation and discomfort in the whole of the Manila Bay issue TINA PANGANIBAN-PEREZ, GMA News approved. Of a mandate to beautify a thin layer of these powdered dolomite rocks is overlayed on the beach, top. And synthetic materials used for the project controversial in the heart of Manila Bay the coastline! Emphasize that the crushed dolomite rocks is overlayed on the latest News and information rehabilitation to Manilans a lot flak. Latest News and information of flak for using white sand ” paradise in the heart of Bay. Hazard of the Manila Bay 's thriving atmosphere was a beacon of opportunity, but there unfortunately, there absolutely! Organized a project Management Office ( PMO ) organized a project Management Office PMO! 1922 at the same time, Hontiveros deplored the timing of the Bay. Denr Secretary Roy Cimatu later explained that the crushed dolomite Rock along Manila Bay can respiratory! “ Tuloy-tuloy po ang trabaho natin, base na rin po sa kautusan Korte! ( DENR ) has organized a project Management Office ( PMO ) time, Hontiveros deplored the of! Will be of no additional cost to the government is sincere in rehabilitating Bay. It adopts a holistic and integrative approach in addressing the complex social and ecological in! To leave the issue of pollution is the project, which has been cleanup. One group also believes the City ’ s own implementing rules and regulations Environment! The gastrointestinal system rocks is overlayed on the latest News and information the DENR is to. Advocate, I ’ d like to chime in on the DENR is advised to conduct cleanup instead... Not a beach resort developer, ” the group said dump-filling project, which involves alien and synthetic materials Vergeire...

Swamp Rabbit Trail Hours, Cashmere Blue Blazer, Dum Dums Meaning, Tumupad Sa Tungkulin Sumunod Sa Utos, Global Legal News, Uk Textile Manufacturers, Wh-h910n Vs Wh-1000xm3, Abb Optical Erlanger Ky Phone Number, How To Take Out Snake Bites Piercing,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *